Afternoon light falls across empty cane-seated chairs and a small sage-curtained stage in an intimate coastal community hall.

Boca Grande's Old Auditorium Is Still Hosting the Season as the New Theater Gets Its Signed Beam Next Door

On the morning of Thursday, Nov. 19, from 10 to 11 a.m., Friends of Boca Grande will set out a steel beam at the Friends Pavilion and invite guests to sign it before it goes into the new theater. Elsewhere on the same campus, the old Auditorium is still busy. Sweet Fleet opened the Boca Grande Live series there on Nov. 10, and on Nov. 17 Christine Kuehn's sold-out "Family of Spies" talk takes the same stage at 4:30 p.m.

That puts two stages on one campus this season. One is in use now, and the other is designed to replace it.

The Room That Still Holds the Season

The Community Center of Boca Grande, at 131 1st St. West, belongs to Lee County. Friends of Boca Grande runs its programming and, under a development agreement with the county, is managing the campus rebuild. The Friends' 2026–27 Happenings Guide says the campus now serves 34 nonprofits.

The Auditorium sits between the building's east and west wings, and Hurricane Milton heavily damaged the Community Center on Oct. 9, 2024. According to the Community Center's post-hurricane roadmap, crews removed damaged floor joists between May and August 2025 and filled the old crawl space under the wings and the existing auditorium with flowable fill and a concrete slab. The roadmap marks that work as completed by Stevens Construction.

Through January, the Guide keeps scheduling into this room. Jeffrey Rosen speaks there on Jan. 11 at 3 p.m., and Brent McConnell's "Bletchley Redux" talk on artificial intelligence follows on Jan. 13 at 4:30 p.m.

What Is Planned Beside It

The new theater is planned for the campus's southeast corner, north of the Island School, on the site of the former multipurpose room. The masterplan calls it a 242-seat theater and auditorium. Stevens Construction's April 2025 announcement describes a 9,200-square-foot, fully accessible building with a larger lobby, more seating and upgraded audio-visual systems. It names Parker/Mudgett/Smith Architects as architect of record.

The roadmap, dated September 2025, sets "5/2026 thru 5/2027" for demolishing the multipurpose room and building the theater. It labels every timeframe as an estimate and subject to change. The Friends' current Guide says the funding campaign is in its last stretch:

"The campaign to fund long-term mitigation is in its final stage, and the project remains on budget and on schedule."

The new building also settles the old Auditorium's future. The Boca Beacon reported in June 2024 that once the new theater is complete, the former auditorium will become multipurpose space for larger functions, with room for duplicate bridge, a black-box performance space and exercise classes, and possibly a fitness center. The masterplan lays out the order of work:

  1. Phase one covers new facilities at the Island School and renovations to the Crowninshield Community House for the Boca Grande Historical Society.
  2. Phase two demolishes the old multipurpose room, builds the new theater, renovates the three historic houses and repurposes space in both wings.
  3. Phase three converts the old auditorium.

So each show in the Auditorium this season is on a stage the plan has already reassigned.

The Crowninshield Already Made Its Move

The 1929 Crowninshield Community House at 240 Banyan St. is a preview of how this plays out. Stevens Construction's 2025 announcement lists the 4,658-square-foot building for renovation of its multipurpose room, foyer, storage, restrooms and workroom. The Boca Grande Historical Society's annual report says the new History Center exhibit room opened to the public there on Nov. 12, 2025, one year to the day before this post publishes.

The Crowninshield is now a working venue in this season's rotation. The Society opened its season there on Nov. 5 with the "Footprints from the Past" exhibit room and the Boca Grande Fishing Hall of Fame tribute wall. History Center tours are listed for Nov. 17 and Nov. 19, with times to be announced. The Friends' Sign & Sip volunteer reception runs there on Dec. 3 from 4:30 to 6 p.m. The Boca Grande Live series also moves into the building in January. Julian Gargiulo's "Classical Unbuttoned" plays the Crowninshield on Jan. 19 at 5 p.m., the series' first stop there after Sweet Fleet opened in the Auditorium.

Reading the Calendar by Room

Here are the campus dates from publication day through January, sorted by building, so the shift between them is easy to follow.

Venue Date Event
Auditorium Tue., Nov. 17, 4:30 p.m. "Family of Spies" with Christine Kuehn, Roger's Picks, sold out
Auditorium Mon., Jan. 11, 3 p.m. Jeffrey Rosen, American Presidents & Politics
Auditorium Wed., Jan. 13, 4:30 p.m. "Bletchley Redux" with Brent McConnell, Critical Issues
Friends Pavilion Thu., Nov. 19, 10 to 11 a.m. "Leave Your Mark" beam signing for the new theater
Friends Pavilion Thu., Jan. 7, 4:30 to 6 p.m. Back to Boca Bash, free outdoor concert
Crowninshield Community House Thu., Dec. 3, 4:30 to 6 p.m. Sign & Sip volunteer reception
Crowninshield Community House Tue., Jan. 19, 5 p.m. "Classical Unbuttoned," Boca Grande Live
Boca Grande History Center, 240 Banyan St. Nov. 17 and Nov. 19, times TBA History Center tours

The Guide invites guests to "kick off the season" at the free Back to Boca Bash on Jan. 7, the start of the busy winter months. Sailing: The Ultimate Yacht Rock Experience plays, Elvis tribute artist Liam Doyle makes a guest appearance, and Friends staff grill free hamburgers and hot dogs. Nana's Bananas brings treats and The Lemonade Express pours drinks. Guests are asked to bring lawn chairs. It shares the Friends Pavilion with the beam signing, which places the January celebration on the same patch of campus where the theater's progress is marked.

The Beam-Signing Morning

The Guide describes the Nov. 19 gathering as "marking the next chapter" of the theater. The program includes remarks from project leaders, light refreshments, and thanks to the Renaissance Donors who funded it. Supporters and anyone interested in getting involved are invited. The Friends event page has details and contact information for anyone who wants to support the theater.

The same evening, the theater's neighbors on Banyan Street open their holiday season. The Boca Grande Art Center at 236 Banyan St. holds a members-only opening reception for "Deck the Walls & More" from 5 to 7 p.m. on Nov. 19. The show then opens to the public from Nov. 20 through Dec. 6, Monday through Saturday 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Sunday 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., closed Thanksgiving. It features small and mid-sized original works by the Art Center's exhibiting members, presented as holiday gift pieces.

Where December Spills Off the Campus

In December, the season leaves the campus and moves into the rest of the Village, a few blocks at a time.

  • Saturday, Dec. 5, 5 to 8 p.m.: The Boca Grande Area Chamber of Commerce Christmas Walk takes over downtown, listed at 301 Park Ave.
  • Same evening, after 5 p.m.: The Boca Grande Historical Society sets up a "Notable Pets of the Island" pop-up exhibit under Gasparilla Outfitters, with holiday treats. Details are on the Historical Society's site.
  • Thursday, Dec. 10, 4 p.m.: The Johann Fust Library Foundation hosts Donna Bulseco in conversation with Daly Walker in the Library Loggia & Courtyard.
  • Dec. 11 and 12, 5 p.m.: The Grande Chorus performs its seasonal program, "Yule be Singin'," at St. Andrew's Episcopal Church. Both performances are free and open to the public, according to the Friends listing.

Over the next few weeks, the Community Center will have a finished building at the Crowninshield, a working stage in the old Auditorium, and a signed beam on its way into the new theater. If you're following the theater's progress from a Village address and want to know how the Banyan Street campus fits into daily island life, Jamie Curry is glad to talk it through. Let's connect.

Work With Jamie

Jamie has worked in the real estate industry for over 15 years and has amassed a renowned class of clientele and unmatched experience.

Follow Me on Instagram